‘Words’ by @mhairihastings1

I’ve been reading a lot over the last 2 years; and I don’t just mean about Edward and Bella.

Cullens

Rather, I have been reading about Innovation, Creativity, Change and Research in healthcare because:

 
1. There is a lot of it going on, a lot more required!
And
2. I am undertaking a Masters Degree

There are a few things that have struck me during this reading, but there is one significant element that I wanted to write about, that which has reassured me about the development and implementation of Active Patient Care within NHS Dumfries and Galloway. (see the end of this Blog entry for more information about Active Patient Care)
The ‘Words’ that we use every day and perhaps don’t particularly think too much about.

 
Let’s take the word ‘Evidence’ first.

Examine
It can mean many different things and we hear it widely used in the media and in social contexts, ‘The evidence was the gun was in their hand’; ‘the evidence is that you have not met your Political Party Agenda’; here it is demonstrating that something happened, or didn’t happen for that matter. Similarly I have been thinking a lot about this use in the context of Nursing. We often talk about ‘if it wasn’t written it wasn’t done’ , interpreted to mean that if we didn’t write down and ‘evidence’ that care was given, we find it difficult to argue that it was. I believe we need to move away from this statement a little, or at least be considering how we provide ‘evidence’, but in a more efficient manner than we currently do. Let’s face it something must be wrong if writing about the care we give takes longer that giving the care – a U turn is required here I would say!

 
Then we have the term ‘Evidence Based Practice’. Used frequently in the context of Nursing since the early 1990’s (following hot on the heels of our Medical colleagues shift to Evidence Based Medicine. It can be used in defence of the care that we gave, or as justification for a particular local and preferred process we are going to use. That in itself I see as a good thing, surely we can’t argue with the concept, but what is the ‘Evidence’ that we refer to, thinking about it as something we can see isn’t particularly helpful. In thinking about that I would ask that you now consider the meaning of two more words.

‘Information’ versus ‘Knowledge

Info
Information: What is Information? Have you ever thought about this before? I think it’s difficult, particularly when you try to interpret a difference between what is ‘Information’ and what is ‘Knowledge.’ Here is what I have decided for myself, but you can make your own mind up. Information is non interpreted facts, raw data i.e. 159 patients attended A&E last Monday; there will be a 1% payrise given to public sector staff; The North West Castle Hotel is situated in Stranraer. What it isn’t saying is ‘Why’ this is the case.

So what is the difference between that and Knowledge? What is Knowledge? Don’t worry about looking this up unless you really feel the need – it is so widely contested you will be reading longer than it took me to read the Twilight Saga and the True Blood series combined!

Books

What I would like you to do is think about my definition, I do get to a point later, honest. ‘Knowledge is a strong belief, which can be justified as true’. (Me! 2013). That’s it. Odd definition to come to? Maybe, but maybe not, Let me explain. The ancient Greeks believe that facts can only become knowledge when someone believes them to be true (information is non interpreted facts, remember what I said above?). Further to this though the facts need to be interpreted and justified. It is in this that the person reading them and believing them to be true becomes a ‘knower’ of this information. They can then claim to have this knowledge, BUT they must then be able to justify why they believe the information to be true. Knowledge is constructed from the information we have at our disposal. A good example of this is that the Earth for a long time was ‘known’ to be flat! New information, which was interpreted and justified was brought to light, people believed it and in the main we now ‘‘know’ that the earth is round.

World

This kind of scientific evidence is always open to disproof though!
There are of course other ways of gaining Knowledge, other than from scientific papers and written information. Think about this one a bit more the next time you can’t explain why you want to give care in a particular way and the ‘evidence’ for it is not in front of you in an Evidence Based Practice Paper, Journal, etc You just want to scream ‘because I just KNOW , ok!’ . Well you’re right, you probably do. You are gaining knowledge in healthcare all the time, the more care you give, the more you interpret individual patients responses to care and begin to believe and ‘know’ that a care method might work with an individual patient. This is Tacit Knowledge – very important, as nurses we have more or less of it depending on experiences and I would strongly encourage it’s use, remember though to ‘know’, you must also be able to justify!

So after all that, I need to explain why all these words have something, anything to do with Active Patient Care. Here’s what I want you to ask yourself now.

1. Do you believe that as nurses or healthcare providers we should continually gather information about how a patient is responding to our fundamental nursing care?

Yes No

2. Do you think that with the patient we should interpret that data, justifying it, agreeing it to be correct?

Yes No

3. Do you agree that you will then have knowledge of the patients’ response to fundamental care?

Yes No

4. With that acquired Knowledge and your previous Tacit Knowledge, do you believe you will be better placed to assist the patient to further plan more care interventions to improve their health and prevent avoidable incidents, such as Falls, Dehydration, Pressure Ulcers?

Yes No

I believe the answer to all of the above is ‘yes’. That answers why all of the above has everything to do with Active Patient Care. You see, Active Patient Care arises from what I believe are the core values and beliefs shared by nurses. As a nurse I believe in The Nursing Process; I believe that no patient should come to harm in our care; I believe that we should always aim for the best possible outcome for and with our patients. We can only do this well if we have easily captured information, which we interpret, know what it means, learn from and use to further plan and implement care with our patients – in this sense it is ‘Evidence’ Based, Patient Centred Practice.

For any nurse that answered ‘No’ to any of the above, I would be more than happy to further discuss and debate with you!

By the way, if Dr Carlisle Cullen applies to work at NHS D&G, I’d be more than happy to show him round Galloway!

Carlisle

Active Patient Care is NHS Dumfries and Galloway’s agreed method of planning, implementing, documenting, assessing and evaluating in patient’s fundamental nursing care. It incorporates both the SKINN Bundle and the basics of Intentional Rounding, but, with the added consideration that it is patient centred, holistic and pro active in its approach. It is planned methodically using the nursing process in order that patients receive care at regular intervals, which are agreed with them and are appropriate to meet their needs without them having to ask for care. This, rather than the standard used with Intentional Rounding, that every patient is seen ever hour but with questionable value to the patient.

Mhairi Hastings is the Nurse Manager for PCCD West, NHS Dumfries and Galloway

7 thoughts on “‘Words’ by @mhairihastings1

  1. A lot of the ‘evidence’ we follow is really just expert opinion which is presented as knowledge but sometimes based on skewed facts.
    …I think?

  2. Pingback: Words | weeklyblogclub

  3. Pingback: Language, art and a bit of elbow grease | weeklyblogclub

  4. “Where is the wisdom we have lost in knowledge? Where is the knowledge we have lost in information?” T.S.Elliot Quote from 1929 –
    agree with your points Mhairi, quite rightly we are becoming more and more accountable for our actions, – but hiding behind statistics and becoming too risk averse, can stifle innovation – often stimulated by gut reactions (Tacit )

  5. I now have the information in your last paragraph but I suppose I will be more knowlegeable if I knew what SKINN Bundle is. Excellent read. Thanks you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s